The quick answer: choose SHEGLAM All-In-One Volume & Length Mascara when you want the most direct route to separated length, lifted curl, and buildable volume. Choose All-In-One 24K Multi-Effect Mascara when you want a similar two-brush routine with a more ingredient-focused formula containing several oils, peptides, panthenol, vitamin E, and gold. Both black mascaras were available at Jamila for EGP 399 when checked on 7 September 2026.
This is a specification, brush, and application comparison based on the current Jamila catalogue and SHEGLAM’s product information. Jamila has not completed a controlled side-by-side wear test, so waterproof, clump-free, lash-care, lift, and volume statements are identified as manufacturer claims rather than guaranteed results.
Choose in 20 seconds
- Choose Volume & Length: for a proven-looking everyday system with a curved silicone brush for lift and separation plus an hourglass brush for stronger volume.
- Choose 24K Multi-Effect: for the same define-then-volume logic with a richer ingredient story and a more dressed-up finish.
- For short or straight lashes: start with the curved brush on either mascara and concentrate at the root.
- For sparse lashes: use the curved brush first, then build only the hourglass side through the roots and outer half.
- For clump-prone lashes: wipe excess from the wand and apply two thin passes instead of one heavy coat.
SHEGLAM Volume & Length vs 24K: comparison table
| Feature | Volume & Length | 24K Multi-Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Current Jamila price | EGP 399 | EGP 399 |
| Current shade | Black | Black |
| Brush system | Curved silicone brush + hourglass brush | Curved brush + hourglass brush |
| Main result | Lift, separation, length and buildable volume | Definition, volume and multi-dimensional fullness |
| Formula emphasis | Waterproof, buildable and clump-free claims | Waterproof performance plus oils, peptides, panthenol, vitamin E and gold |
| Best starting point | Performance-first everyday or evening mascara | Ingredient-focused, full-lash finish |
| Jamila wear test | Not conducted | Not conducted |
The two products overlap more than their packaging suggests. Both use two brush shapes so you can define first and add volume second. The decision is less about one being universally “better” and more about whether you value the established performance-focused formula or the additional ingredient story of the 24K version.
All-In-One Volume & Length Mascara
Best for controlled length, separation and adjustable volume
The original All-In-One combines two applicators. SHEGLAM describes the curved silicone brush as a nine-row design with two loading arches that can reach small lashes while lifting, curling, and separating them. The hourglass brush is designed to fan the lashes and add thicker-looking volume.
This makes it the simpler choice when you want to control each stage. Use only the curved side for a cleaner daytime look, add the hourglass side for fuller roots, or combine both for stronger definition.
Best match: short, straight, uneven, or clump-prone lashes where separation matters as much as volume.
How its two brushes divide the work
Curved brush: place the inner curve against the roots, pause briefly, then comb upward. Turn the tip vertically for inner corners and lower lashes.
Hourglass brush: keep most of the product at the base and outer half of the lashes. This creates density without loading the fine tips so heavily that they stick together.
The current store listing describes the formula as buildable, waterproof, long-lasting, and clump-free. Those are SHEGLAM claims. Removal may require a dedicated waterproof eye-makeup remover rather than ordinary face wash.
All-In-One 24K Multi-Effect Mascara
Best for a fuller result with an ingredient-focused formula
The 24K version keeps the two-step define-and-volumize idea but places more attention on the formula. Its current ingredient list includes panthenol, vitamin E, several plant oils, multiple peptides, and gold. SHEGLAM describes the result as full-bodied, lifted, and multi-dimensional.
These ingredients do not turn mascara into a lash-growth treatment. The formula sits on the lashes temporarily, and the presence of gold does not by itself prove better length, strength, or growth. Choose this version because you prefer its formula concept and finish, not because you expect it to replace a tested lash serum.
Best match: anyone who wants definition and volume but prefers the 24K product’s ingredient profile and premium presentation.
The best order for the 24K brushes
SHEGLAM’s current application visual recommends using the curved brush to comb and separate individual lashes, following with the hourglass brush to build volume, then returning to the curved brush to coat and lift the lashes evenly.
That final separating pass is useful only while the product is still flexible. Once a waterproof coat has dried, repeated combing can create flakes or pull at the lashes. Work on one eye at a time and stop when the desired shape is clean.
Which mascara suits your lash type?
Short lashes
Begin with the curved brush from root to tip. Wiggle only at the base, then pull straight through the ends so the tips remain separated. Volume & Length is the more direct choice if visible extension and precise separation are your priority.
Straight lashes that lose their curl
Curl clean, dry lashes before mascara. Press the curved brush gently into the roots and hold for a moment before lifting. Keep the second coat thin because excess weight can pull the curl down. Both products are sold as waterproof at Jamila, but curl retention will still differ by lash texture and climate.
Sparse lashes
Use the hourglass brush mainly at the roots, where darkness creates the strongest impression of density. Add a second pass to the outer third for a lifted eye shape. Either mascara can work; choose 24K if you prefer its richer formula concept, or Volume & Length if you want the clearest performance-first option.
Dense lashes that clump easily
Remove visible excess from the brush neck, then use the curved side to comb through small sections. Do not start with the hourglass side loaded with product. The original Volume & Length is the stronger starting recommendation because its separation brush is the main reason to choose it.
Small eyes or hard-to-reach lashes
Hold the curved brush vertically and use only its tip on the inner corners and lower lash line. Keep the eye looking slightly downward when coating the upper roots to reduce transfer onto the lid.
How to get volume without clumps
- Remove oil and skincare residue. Gently blot the lashes if eye cream or sunscreen has reached them.
- Curl before mascara. Never clamp a standard lash curler over dry waterproof mascara because the lashes can stick and break.
- Wipe the wand neck. A large blob at the brush tip creates clumps before application even begins.
- Define first. Use the curved brush to coat from the base and separate the tips.
- Add volume while flexible. Apply the hourglass side before the first layer becomes completely dry.
- Stop after the shape is even. More passes do not always mean more volume; they can join clean lash groups into spikes.
Waterproof wear and safe removal
Waterproof mascara is useful for heat, humidity, watery eyes, and long events, but stronger wear usually means more careful removal. Saturate a cotton pad with a remover labelled for waterproof eye makeup, hold it over the closed eye for 15–30 seconds, then slide downward gently. Repeat rather than scrubbing from side to side.
Remove mascara before sleep, keep the wand inside its own tube, and never share eye makeup. Stop using the product if it causes persistent burning, redness, swelling, or unusual watering. Marketing terms such as “sensitive-eye safe” do not guarantee compatibility for every person or contact-lens wearer.
Does the 24K formula justify choosing it?
At Jamila’s current price, there is no price penalty: both mascaras were EGP 399. The 24K formula lists a wide mixture of oils and peptides, but mascara performance still depends heavily on brush control, film formation, drying speed, and removal. Choose 24K if the formula and presentation appeal to you. Choose Volume & Length if you want to keep the decision centered on lash shape and brush function.
The gold version is also newer-looking and more decorative, which may make it a better gift. The original black-and-teal tube feels more practical and immediately communicates the two brush functions. Packaging is a preference, not evidence that one formula is more effective.
Frequently asked questions
Which SHEGLAM mascara is better for length?
Volume & Length is the clearer first choice because length, lift, curl, and separation are the central purpose of its curved silicone brush. The 24K version can also define and lift, but its positioning places more emphasis on multi-effect fullness and ingredients.
Which is better for dramatic volume?
Both include an hourglass brush for volume. The 24K version is positioned for full-bodied, multi-dimensional lashes, while the original lets you build from a clean separated base. Application amount may make a larger difference than the product name.
Are both mascaras waterproof?
Both current Jamila listings label the products waterproof. The original SHEGLAM page also explicitly describes Volume & Length as waterproof. Treat this as a manufacturer claim and use a waterproof eye-makeup remover.
Can 24K gold make lashes grow?
The ingredient list includes gold and peptides, but that does not establish the product as a lash-growth treatment. No growth promise is made in this guide.
Can I use only one end?
Yes. Use the curved side alone for cleaner definition, the hourglass side for faster density, or both in sequence. For the neatest result, start with the curved brush.
Final recommendation
Buy Volume & Length if you want the most straightforward everyday choice for controlled lift, separation, and volume. Buy 24K Multi-Effect if you want a similar two-brush system with a richer ingredient profile and premium gold presentation. Because both currently cost EGP 399, the decision can stay focused on your lash goal rather than price.
Explore more choices in our Best SHEGLAM Products in Egypt guide, and use the SHEGLAM original vs fake buying checklist before ordering from an unfamiliar source. Then complete your base with the SHEGLAM primer comparison, or take the Jamila Beauty Quiz for a more personal routine direction.
Editorial note: Price, stock, product information, and images were checked on 7 September 2026 and can change. Jamila has not conducted a controlled side-by-side wear test. Performance descriptions are attributed to SHEGLAM or identified as practical application guidance.
Sources: SHEGLAM All-In-One Volume & Length Mascara; SHEGLAM All-In-One 24K Multi-Effect Mascara. Editorial hero photo by Aleks on Pexels. Product images belong to SHEGLAM and are served from Jamila’s product catalogue.
